Alberta offers the greatest degree of school choice in Canada, according to the Barbara Mitchell Centre's cross-country comparison Measuring Choice and Competition in Canadian Education. Public, separate, francophone, charter and independent schools; home education; online learning; and alternative programs inside the public and separate systems.
So choice exists. The question is whether it is real.
Two freedoms
Authentic education choice needs two things at once:
- Parents must be free to reach a setting that meets their child's needs and honours the family's culture and values.
- Schools must be free to provide a setting that meets the expectations of the families who chose it.
Each can be hollowed out while the school types stay on the books. A parent's freedom is compromised when some options are funded and others must be paid for twice, once in taxes and once in fees; income then decides. It is compromised when regulation caps the number of charter schools or a board refuses to expand a program families are lining up for. A school's freedom is compromised when the province dictates a teaching method, or a law forces a principal to permit school-wide activities on a student's demand with no regard for the school community. It is compromised when one kind of school is held to monitoring and annual permission to operate that another kind never faces.
The test for any proposed change is one question: will it enhance or impede the capacity of parents to reach, and schools to provide, authentic choice?
Why it matters
A 2019 report by Mark Milke and Paige MacPherson, commissioned in part by PCE, put it plainly: students have a range of needs and interests, and maximizing diversity in the system is how a public system serves that reality. An independent school, a charter school or home education may fit a child's learning better than the neighbourhood school. A focus on sport, music or culture may be what keeps a child in school at all.
Choice does three things. It fits the education to the child, because children do not come one-size-fits-all. It produces graduates whose skills differ, which is what a province needs. And it raises quality everywhere, because a school that must be chosen must earn the choice.
Four pillars
- Equitable funding. Choice that only the wealthy can afford is not choice. See Facts on funding.
- Curriculum and resources. Schools must be able to select the methods and materials that fit their setting and their families' expectations.
- Parent autonomy. Only a fully informed parent can judge whether a setting is working, and only a parent free to leave can act on that judgement. Any law or policy that withholds information from parents, or traps a child in a setting, erodes both. See Parental rights and the law.
- Local decision-making. The people closest to the students need real authority. Red tape from the centre undermines it.